The Bible and Society

How God’s Word is True

“Uneducated girls are more innocent and easier to control”

Posted by Mats on 27/01/2009

A consequence of the enshrinement of Muhammad’s consummating his marriage to Aisha when she was 9 years old as a laudable act, worthy of imitating (Qur’an 33:21), is not only the stigmatization of “older” would-be brides, but that “older” is actually rather young. Hence, according to this article, the marriage of very young girls is actually on the rise.

Islam elevates women, we’re told, if only sharia were ever implemented “correctly.” But like communism, sharia has just never gone quite as it is advertised for Western consumption. “Marriage Choice for Women in Yemen: Early Marriage or No Marriage,” by Abdul Rahim Al-Showthabi for the Yemen Post, January 19:

“I’m not young anymore to get married. I am in my late thirties so it is not easy,” said 38 year-old and primary school teacher Mona.

The norms of our society compel a woman to make unsatisfied choices to marry as early as possible or to remain single beyond the usual age. However, thousands of women struggle during the time they remain unmarried.

According to a new study conducted by researcher Shuroog Ba-Mogbl, more than half a million women go above their thirties and still stay unmarried. Also the motive behind spinster was revealed as the society has negative thoughts towards working women.

“Hearing negative comments about educated women, I prefer to marry uneducated rural girls as I believe that uneducated girls are more innocent and easier to control,” said 27 year old Rashid Al-Sa’di.

Perhaps he has heard this Yemeni proverb: “Give me a girl of 8, and I can give you a guarantee [for a good marriage].”

“If we can liberate ourselves a little from having bad feelings towards educated women, we won’t have the big crisis of early marriage in Yemen,” said lawyer and human rights activist Afra Hariri. “People’s way of thinking towards educated women and divorced ones raises the issue of spinster in the country” she added.

In Sana’a theaters next Friday the 13th: Night of the Educated “Spinster”.

Belqis Al-Lahabi a human rights activist who also passed through struggles of being unmarried, said that educated women often prefer to marry wealthy men and this is one reason for the delay of their marriages, which also leads them to marry older men.

Is “wealthy” defined with the same low threshold as “old enough for marriage?”

Sociology professor at Sana’a University Adel Al-Sharjabi said that late marriage is believed to be a crisis not only in Yemen but also in all Arab countries. “The period of time in which the woman stays unmarried is harmful as her behavior is watched and her movements are monitored more than others,” he added.

In a country where many older women are struggling to get married, the rate of early marriages are increasing dramatically. The wait that older women go through leads younger women to get married as early as possible.

“I don’t know anything about my childhood only a girl who had to bring water from a far away water wells,” said 28 year-old Daula Hassan who got married 15 years ago to a man in her father’s age. “If I have something to regret, it is my childhood,” she added.

Volunteer lawyer of (Nujood, Arwa and Reem,) who all got married before the age of 14, Shatha Nasser said that the reasons that led her clients’ families to accept early marriages for their daughters was their parents financial reasons.

There is a deeper problem with a system of values that considers bartering one’s daughter as an option in the face of financial difficulty.

The law before 1990 stated that the girl must reach the age of sixteen to get married and any marriage before the limited age is a crime and those who violate the law must be imprisoned not less than a year and not more than three years and pay money for the woman as a compensation.

“It is a potential risk that men turn to marry younger girls and leave adult ones,” said Head of the Sister Arab Forum for Human Rights, Amal Basha.

Researcher and parliament member Faud Dahabh believes that under age marriage is not permitted in Sharia if it harms the girl. He went on that numerous cases of early marriages assured that many girls were harmed when they got married early.

“If it harms the girl.” And what transparent, verifiable system is in place to ascertain that?

Sana’a university faculty of law professor Abdul Mo’men Shuja’ Al-Dein said that the new law does not make it clear as it states that the marriage of the child girl is illegal.” “The law also states that the silence of a woman when asked for marriage is a sign of acceptance and this law is against the international agreements that Yemen signed,” he added.

Locals who got married at a early age describe their practice of sex with their wives to bakers who bake bread in cold ovens.

That crass and insensitive analogy aside, one would think some of them might recognize that as sign that child marriage is not such a great idea.

Professor and jurisprudence’s professor and ex-head of the Faculty of Law Sana’a University Hassan Al-Ahdel stated that it is not fair to force a female child to get married early because such a marriage could result to many problems.

He revealed that famous Islamic scholars as Abu Hainfah fixes marriage age at 18 and considers this age to be the minimum, because a man or a woman becomes full-grown and able to take decisions out of his own sense and consideration.

It will take much more than one anecdote about a favorable minimum marriage age to genuinely solve the problem. The opinion of one scholar — however famous — against the example of Muhammad, and the fact that the Qur’an takes child marriage for granted in allowing for divorce of girls who have not reached puberty (65:4) will not sway those who are determined to maintain child marriage. Only a broad consensus against it, stated in unequivocal terms, with the support of civil laws and clerics who will refuse to be party to child marriages will pave the way for progress. Insisting that it isn’t really Islamic (except when it kind of is, but it’s complicated) will not.

Early marriage is one of the biggest development challenges in Yemen according to Naseem-Ur-Rehman, Chief Information Officer at UNICEF Sana’a. A 2006 field study revealed that child marriage among Yemeni girls reached 52.1%, compared to 6.7% among males. The study, conducted by the Woman and Development Study Center, affiliated to Sana’a University, looked at 1,495 couples.

Posted by Marisol at January 19, 2009 12:01 AM


One Response to ““Uneducated girls are more innocent and easier to control””

  1. Early, childhood, marriage remains a problem in a large segment of the Indian population also. Though we have laws against, it is difficult to enforce due to illiteracy.

    Johnson C. Philip, PhD (Physics)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: